tDAR Logo tDAR digital antiquity

Delineating Ancestral Tribal Territories in Western Washington Based on Flawed Interpretations of Historic Records and Archaeology: A Review of Contemporary Practices and Consequences

Author(s): Dennis Lewarch

Year: 2015

» Downloads & Basic Metadata

Summary

Historians and anthropologists have reviewed the history of problems associated with delineating tribes and tribal territories in Western Washington, noting often uncritical acceptance of historic records at face value, such as failure to consider the context, goals, and cultural viewpoints of those generating records.  Such problems, unfortunately, persist in contemporary contexts where tribes create fictional histories to accommodate modern political and economic goals.  Here I review flawed interpretations of historic records and archaeology for Admiralty Inlet and Puget Sound that derive from legal cases associated with treaty-reserved rights to fish, hunt, and harvest shellfish and crab.  Consequences of flawed scholarship extend beyond treaty-reserved access to resources that have economic effects, to projection of cultural hegemony by some tribes to rewrite histories and to force public agencies to ignore legitimate histories and claims of other tribes, including access to traditional cultural historic landscapes and claims to ancestral archaeological resources.


This Resource is Part of the Following Collections


Cite this Record

Delineating Ancestral Tribal Territories in Western Washington Based on Flawed Interpretations of Historic Records and Archaeology: A Review of Contemporary Practices and Consequences. Dennis Lewarch. Presented at Society for Historical Archaeology, Seattle, Washington. 2015 ( tDAR id: 434067)


Keywords


Spatial Coverage

min long: -129.199; min lat: 24.495 ; max long: -66.973; max lat: 49.359 ;

Record Identifiers

PaperId(s): 492

Arizona State University The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation National Science Foundation National Endowment for the Humanities Society for American Archaeology Archaeological Institute of America